``Congruent number curves'' ny2=x3-x
with |n| congruent to 7 mod 8 and less than ten million
with rank at least 3, assuming the conjecture of Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer

In this page we reported and used the list of |n|=8k+7<106 for which the ``congruent number'' curve

E(n): n y2 = x3 - x

has analytic rank at least 3.

Extending this computation to 107 would take about two weeks on a 500MHz machine running the same gp program. But most of this time would be spent on values of |n| for which E(n) can be proved to have rank at most 1 by a 2-descent between E(n) and the 2-isogenous curve ny2=x3+4x. [As n grows, the bound from this 2-descent on the rank of E(n) exceeds any given integer r with probability approaching 100%; but this approach is very slow, and of the integers |n|=8k+7<107, only 16.2% pass this test even for r=1.]

For the 106 computation, it was worthwhile to try all n, including those (86% in that range) for which the arithmetic rank cannot exceed 1, because this made it possible to prove that every E(n) in that range with |n|=8k+7 has positive rank. But we do not expect to be able in reasonable time to find a non-torsion point on each of the 2392 curves listed below. Thus we carried out the computation only for those |n|=8k+7<107 that also passed the 2-descent test for rank at least 3. Hence we cannot claim unconditionally to have listed all cases of analytic rank at least 3 with |n|=8k+7<107; but we do know that the list is complete assuming the ``analytic rank = arithmetic rank'' conjecture of Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer.

Actually one also needs the assumption that none of these curves has a nonzero Heegner point that is numerically indistinguishable from a torsion point. I set the threshold to 10-8, working in 19-digit precision, but in fact all points below that threshold were within 10-15 of a torsion point.

A graph (PostScript, landscape mode) of the function f(N)={number of |n|<N in the list} can be found here.


4199 4895 6671 9015 10199 12935 15655 16151 16887 23359 28007 29055 32039 32599 35719 36519 41151 41943 50583 51359 55279 58695 59415 60119 60415 60847 61815 65535 65639 68295 68839 69015 70959 72151 73055 73151 76479 80015 81959 83159 94655 95095 99231 100711 103159 103727 105735 106711 112119 113919 119255 124815 128263 128935 129935 132559 137111 137671 142071 142471 143903 145439 148215 149495 152095 153439 157591 159999 164119 168823 170671 172639 186295 191735 194439 202279 202623 202935 206079 211055 211935 212815 213231 213455 215895 216039 220215 221879 223727 225607 226159 226335 230815 234255 235911 238791 241039 242351 245479 246559 249135 250271 254535 256039 257439 259311 259831 260015 261919 263495 266695 267415 267735 269535 271551 273023 281271 287079 288615 293415 293455 294063 301335 306631 307247 310295 318655 319871 324911 327543 327711 329063 329415 331215 334055 334631 336399 342127 344311 350895 351799 352839 353855 355607 362455 365087 367807 372215 373711 374415 381983 382215 383831 385535 392231 393679 394719 394927 394935 395319 396799 401135 404551 405015 408319 408559 412055 413663 416879 423599 424479 424535 433879 434135 435455 437871 442335 448663 450079 450255 451191 458311 459543 463287 465727 473263 478239 488047 488215 488607 490919 492479 493647 498095 506391 508335 509415 509615 511879 513383 514759 521255 524095 524167 525215 529679 530503 534359 538215 542095 550511 553735 555719 572631 601455 603519 606599 611391 617999 622391 622679 625439 631031 631687 637935 640159 640815 642295 645351 650695 653815 656095 661055 664215 667615 668247 669151 675591 692479 694991 698295 700151 705399 708135 716887 722055 729735 730655 732279 737295 738255 738335 739159 740391 743399 745503 746351 746511 754151 758095 758535 762559 770959 777439 781255 783439 789495 789559 789735 790727 792143 800079 801879 811855 817071 821215 822647 824735 830031 830319 835863 836591 839399 839759 840487 850367 852295 852663 857679 862223 873871 876143 880815 888063 889935 891215 893535 897519 898215 898247 900271 904255 905519 905695 908895 911031 916255 916391 918255 925519 928855 929591 929999 934199 935879 937167 938231 938311 939455 941215 941239 946151 946567 954551 954655 957615 959871 961495 965543 965671 966847 977015 977943 978711 981615 985647 990647 991039 996079 1000495 1005279 1006415 1007367 1008095 1009079 1016335 1017127 1021447 1022431 1023287 1028783 1033879 1043095 1054119 1059495 1060031 1060639 1063095 1067495 1076271 1082711 1084807 1084935 1093735 1096095 1096439 1100159 1102183 1102759 1104207 1105951 1108383 1108495 1112919 1114055 1115335 1125039 1125847 1134359 1137895 1141615 1146191 1149495 1151119 1155135 1160471 1161615 1165871 1166263 1172135 1174935 1176655 1176959 1177319 1179399 1186511 1190031 1190119 1194151 1194991 1196551 1197735 1200991 1201231 1207999 1214455 1216551 1216911 1219103 1224663 1224727 1227135 1229223 1229711 1238159 1241079 1244047 1251807 1252535 1255655 1256351 1256647 1258759 1263535 1265799 1266135 1266783 1280607 1282439 1286719 1303455 1310095 1310439 1312199 1324895 1329135 1329447 1330855 1336335 1337039 1340519 1341879 1342271 1342671 1344295 1345935 1351103 1351231 1353111 1356415 1356839 1358311 1365855 1366287 1366711 1373855 1374079 1374735 1375687 1385735 1388631 1392495 1393415 1395015 1404151 1404703 1405055 1422079 1431735 1433287 1437655 1441039 1441711 1448831 1448839 1449871 1454719 1457591 1468815 1470119 1478631 1480983 1483959 1488095 1494839 1509311 1509527 1514359 1515991 1518927 1522095 1522495 1527071 1530615 1531135 1531615 1533055 1534695 1541207 1542671 1545719 1547895 1551727 1553559 1563751 1573431 1575015 1580159 1581231 1582095 1582631 1585927 1586487 1588535 1589095 1589959 1593295 1600215 1607071 1613047 1614431 1617599 1630207 1630447 1634495 1636151 1638319 1640095 1647735 1648335 1648711 1649231 1651695 1654015 1655895 1657279 1657495 1658319 1661263 1663319 1664039 1670255 1674239 1678935 1678991 1680679 1685335 1695007 1696871 1701071 1702295 1709167 1715719 1717487 1719055 1736295 1738279 1741439 1744919 1747343 1749111 1758183 1760271 1760415 1763903 1766791 1766999 1775519 1781383 1781439 1782431 1784087 1785791 1786135 1786351 1790407 1791671 1805655 1825063 1835351 1837623 1848335 1851279 1851335 1855319 1855711 1870799 1871079 1880535 1880599 1886079 1892735 1896719 1897679 1901479 1906567 1908071 1908519 1910279 1921759 1933087 1934639 1936623 1944239 1947055 1948303 1953583 1953895 1954511 1955135 1955167 1959159 1964503 1970447 1971255 1972191 1972391 1974367 1980695 1981519 1982695 1986023 1986095 1989255 1992039 1993335 1994111 1995455 2007751 2018391 2025311 2028071 2031911 2040031 2041151 2041711 2049031 2049871 2057527 2059055 2059935 2060151 2060799 2063399 2067495 2077279 2077751 2082615 2082639 2083911 2086231 2088015 2088559 2092751 2093567 2098871 2110335 2124519 2125695 2136927 2140535 2143295 2152319 2154815 2159079 2163871 2167815 2169039 2180399 2190623 2196311 2197455 2202343 2206183 2206855 2209927 2213751 2216535 2221751 2222183 2222535 2225839 2228063 2234895 2236895 2242695 2243199 2244767 2246207 2256071 2262343 2267239 2268895 2279231 2281439 2281615 2282735 2283879 2285751 2287911 2299143 2301359 2302055 2303455 2305023 2307615 2308039 2310719 2310815 2315159 2315487 2319015 2319999 2324287 2328999 2335983 2336095 2344615 2349319 2352511 2360495 2360535 2365231 2367471 2368255 2370415 2371999 2375639 2383799 2387255 2388071 2392831 2398519 2400799 2402887 2429191 2429679 2430415 2433151 2449615 2452439 2457663 2463807 2463839 2464703 2468039 2469615 2472455 2497111 2508071 2514983 2516239 2521135 2521927 2526591 2539551 2541959 2549631 2554359 2557271 2559759 2559999 2562487 2564503 2585039 2586655 2598815 2602535 2607119 2608807 2610863 2615815 2616271 2621455 2625055 2630847 2644591 2648815 2650055 2650719 2669615 2672007 2673335 2679391 2683311 2684311 2699671 2709687 2712327 2713215 2715087 2719031 2721815 2721831 2724735 2725151 2728887 2731695 2731735 2734615 2735895 2737207 2739543 2742439 2747399 2749079 2750839 2750943 2755599 2755751 2756879 2761759 2765679 2771839 2779063 2780855 2784223 2789319 2789759 2796015 2797015 2800815 2804415 2822831 2826871 2827495 2831119 2831855 2832135 2835735 2845239 2847543 2848287 2848391 2851471 2863911 2864807 2871895 2895095 2899015 2904007 2907951 2915151 2916015 2917439 2921183 2927359 2927463 2929895 2931623 2934271 2943103 2945263 2953815 2958215 2965495 2965735 2969455 2971759 2990215 2996391 2997551 3007599 3008895 3009279 3010631 3014871 3015943 3025631 3025743 3027687 3029871 3036295 3037535 3038703 3041511 3045623 3049431 3052743 3058895 3063991 3067567 3075231 3085503 3085607 3092239 3092863 3094215 3094735 3097055 3098415 3111119 3111695 3113455 3116615 3118031 3119655 3121279 3131679 3133015 3141679 3154847 3155815 3158511 3163719 3165559 3165791 3167951 3170711 3172855 3174015 3182263 3183263 3193591 3195335 3198047 3198287 3205631 3210751 3211431 3213615 3214823 3226511 3226719 3229735 3238015 3241631 3242135 3242215 3243207 3247255 3267231 3276015 3277687 3278015 3280223 3282279 3285735 3289727 3291535 3292023 3292151 3296135 3298911 3301935 3304335 3306615 3308615 3318463 3321735 3330607 3330735 3338103 3344055 3347167 3350487 3357471 3358615 3359031 3369711 3379519 3384511 3384703 3387599 3388935 3391311 3392935 3394111 3399671 3406151 3410535 3415215 3418023 3420951 3425455 3439695 3452615 3458591 3462135 3463031 3464759 3468255 3468751 3468983 3476815 3479935 3484031 3494335 3495791 3507119 3510455 3512919 3519551 3521135 3529591 3530751 3534815 3538199 3545423 3548415 3548495 3553935 3555687 3562151 3563295 3568591 3569983 3572535 3575831 3575879 3580527 3585119 3587071 3587735 3592695 3597047 3601487 3604111 3607751 3611335 3622559 3624159 3626327 3632511 3633871 3645055 3648055 3652807 3662967 3664815 3665519 3668215 3668351 3669143 3672663 3674391 3675615 3680159 3686727 3691799 3697215 3697351 3704759 3711183 3714599 3717055 3721271 3733431 3734679 3737855 3745695 3746351 3751735 3756655 3758615 3763207 3764535 3765055 3781039 3782231 3783423 3784151 3784911 3785047 3789559 3790671 3791279 3794871 3799087 3806239 3807687 3810431 3818455 3819855 3831895 3838639 3842639 3846431 3850919 3855039 3872303 3879031 3883055 3884415 3885447 3888031 3901495 3909439 3913207 3916463 3920455 3921351 3922719 3923823 3926671 3926863 3928639 3929703 3932719 3934671 3939015 3944663 3945167 3948159 3955159 3956127 3956519 3958919 3960647 3961679 3967439 3973335 3979471 3980431 3985215 3989095 3994895 4001647 4004519 4006335 4017695 4024295 4031111 4040967 4041143 4041903 4045839 4046191 4047655 4048159 4050807 4057071 4063215 4067111 4067511 4071319 4072127 4081495 4087951 4088487 4091631 4094111 4095559 4099543 4110511 4111215 4112543 4112639 4116039 4122671 4123095 4129895 4142159 4143407 4146623 4148079 4150895 4152719 4152743 4154215 4176991 4179335 4181983 4185519 4188527 4190415 4193943 4195295 4197495 4198839 4198935 4200839 4206911 4207855 4213671 4219519 4220335 4224823 4224935 4225735 4233319 4233391 4234495 4238879 4238895 4239735 4245871 4246039 4246471 4249711 4253695 4255935 4261831 4263455 4266079 4269527 4272135 4272695 4274031 4276095 4280783 4288135 4296607 4298671 4302615 4307295 4313855 4316271 4318687 4326303 4327215 4331199 4345095 4349135 4352431 4355351 4361919 4364535 4370439 4370671 4374615 4375839 4379991 4390471 4398727 4399583 4410271 4414335 4435671 4443439 4447311 4452055 4462815 4464815 4465703 4467007 4476255 4478303 4490759 4497055 4499191 4506439 4510335 4512047 4515623 4519799 4522135 4526335 4529735 4529887 4532591 4551919 4557615 4572255 4576055 4580719 4588415 4591303 4592991 4595615 4602759 4605391 4619535 4620855 4624503 4625999 4629183 4629263 4630015 4630751 4634167 4635039 4643471 4647999 4659207 4664239 4687127 4692023 4694295 4695271 4697231 4699631 4702055 4702199 4702255 4704559 4706759 4712007 4712591 4714559 4715599 4725695 4725831 4727719 4729935 4733215 4734415 4735055 4739759 4754895 4757079 4764767 4767191 4768855 4770719 4773255 4774207 4774399 4780223 4781719 4782415 4788431 4791031 4800863 4802655 4806319 4807335 4819503 4819999 4825615 4828471 4830655 4839135 4847135 4848655 4864295 4866031 4871391 4871639 4888095 4889391 4894759 4895191 4898239 4900279 4906295 4926143 4926615 4932543 4933199 4934719 4942319 4943135 4949623 4952383 4952391 4966239 4967135 4978135 4979487 4980815 4986151 4986735 4986759 5003399 5005855 5009199 5015303 5015735 5021751 5022311 5024255 5033535 5034255 5039015 5040519 5041167 5042991 5044695 5051559 5051783 5057767 5057999 5058735 5063471 5064295 5066815 5102727 5102895 5109167 5113615 5113743 5128895 5133271 5133999 5134447 5139127 5139519 5141055 5141671 5144919 5148983 5149767 5150991 5157911 5169839 5172063 5175047 5189359 5192831 5196079 5202015 5212727 5216279 5218135 5228535 5243399 5244063 5244679 5246039 5246967 5254751 5256167 5259783 5260143 5283759 5285639 5294607 5299431 5300295 5303543 5312143 5313679 5318359 5320991 5329471 5332839 5336695 5341767 5344415 5359567 5360335 5360415 5362007 5379031 5380215 5382839 5389679 5392295 5394319 5403503 5409431 5413359 5417839 5418791 5419167 5421031 5422991 5426215 5426655 5429991 5437495 5438615 5454215 5461311 5463719 5466791 5467839 5468567 5474279 5477591 5487223 5499015 5503799 5504135 5505479 5506295 5514935 5515495 5530335 5531295 5535519 5537903 5542719 5549055 5557071 5559359 5564703 5569895 5571223 5574671 5578527 5584103 5585527 5594239 5598591 5608055 5608831 5614039 5614471 5615119 5618919 5619719 5624087 5626919 5632711 5638543 5641511 5644535 5651951 5655895 5659639 5664695 5665639 5672639 5673751 5675015 5676751 5677295 5682279 5686055 5686935 5688079 5696839 5700695 5701551 5703223 5707583 5712711 5713895 5718559 5723135 5724159 5734415 5738703 5740735 5749255 5757383 5762711 5768535 5776719 5782895 5784431 5784799 5796047 5811639 5814791 5817695 5818215 5821959 5835319 5854279 5855791 5857663 5858535 5865119 5872607 5873567 5877655 5894599 5894735 5905263 5908791 5915735 5917359 5918871 5921671 5929159 5945111 5952295 5955551 5955735 5961599 5968879 5970135 5973359 5977191 5985631 5997999 5999935 6001255 6003151 6003615 6005599 6010711 6012391 6018415 6029359 6047535 6050135 6058423 6059663 6064039 6065119 6066439 6069343 6073535 6076399 6082351 6083103 6089695 6092383 6103079 6104559 6106103 6113415 6133719 6135015 6136487 6137759 6140199 6141903 6154935 6156247 6167015 6173903 6178271 6183527 6184119 6187071 6187407 6189095 6190215 6190223 6208559 6211991 6224199 6224831 6225999 6227871 6240255 6246935 6251791 6252431 6259519 6262095 6263831 6267495 6278471 6283095 6296455 6299583 6304519 6307455 6308295 6315351 6318055 6318223 6328959 6333535 6333639 6335839 6338535 6340295 6349111 6349127 6351455 6352543 6353599 6355895 6364839 6365119 6375103 6375623 6376695 6376879 6378159 6379583 6387495 6388935 6404951 6407087 6409799 6411319 6412711 6413711 6414735 6416143 6417295 6423015 6424023 6426959 6433255 6433351 6447935 6453167 6453951 6454095 6464343 6465615 6466703 6467415 6468215 6470319 6475031 6475895 6480383 6486135 6489023 6500711 6504095 6510255 6514783 6517263 6518959 6529439 6532599 6533207 6536807 6541639 6546751 6548095 6551799 6552535 6553551 6558639 6559895 6570959 6595071 6600767 6605231 6612303 6619879 6630639 6632311 6632855 6641759 6644719 6654999 6662599 6663239 6667215 6682631 6682711 6697015 6699695 6705543 6706135 6706687 6713935 6714071 6714303 6714799 6720335 6722735 6732479 6757863 6758295 6773327 6777615 6778735 6780207 6781711 6787151 6788535 6795719 6816711 6819351 6822263 6822967 6838135 6861135 6862791 6864879 6878679 6899279 6928031 6931279 6937183 6949039 6949511 6949815 6954095 6959271 6974495 6975031 6975311 6981351 6981455 6990151 6993631 7000079 7002215 7002431 7003239 7004063 7004535 7014839 7016863 7018039 7022015 7023655 7029519 7030407 7031863 7049391 7050719 7051655 7053735 7055815 7061255 7061335 7065799 7066815 7075471 7077567 7079735 7084199 7084679 7091567 7094327 7099527 7103735 7106351 7108199 7114303 7120191 7120335 7132319 7136967 7141487 7141895 7142487 7143895 7158839 7163455 7166695 7174455 7175463 7176655 7178359 7179887 7190399 7191255 7199759 7205159 7218047 7222863 7225351 7230599 7235255 7235431 7242311 7246351 7252319 7256095 7257295 7257327 7271335 7280031 7281807 7287343 7288535 7291679 7294623 7296079 7296807 7302223 7303535 7305055 7309855 7313215 7313631 7318047 7321015 7323959 7325839 7325895 7328615 7334439 7335551 7341823 7344911 7345191 7354831 7356727 7367943 7374559 7377559 7390319 7396415 7401839 7405455 7414615 7414815 7415655 7417247 7418455 7426335 7427335 7427399 7429695 7431047 7451407 7455935 7456007 7458791 7463599 7473991 7475359 7479439 7487735 7493503 7507983 7518199 7519583 7523615 7534271 7540455 7549135 7561055 7562399 7566015 7569303 7570479 7572271 7575119 7576159 7576647 7586159 7587735 7588183 7591935 7598255 7603447 7605239 7609999 7610495 7622679 7623287 7623735 7634055 7637295 7652023 7655295 7667359 7671335 7675359 7685151 7686095 7704679 7705815 7711095 7715567 7718199 7727311 7731399 7738655 7740911 7750959 7755015 7769535 7772599 7794735 7802311 7805671 7806487 7808015 7809359 7810431 7810639 7811823 7812831 7819167 7821359 7831135 7833215 7833255 7835111 7839015 7843295 7848735 7859631 7864935 7865599 7874247 7876559 7886183 7887495 7893335 7893767 7893871 7906015 7916839 7919431 7922143 7928519 7934279 7934399 7944079 7944695 7955111 7958015 7959655 7961055 7965655 7968391 7975463 7979415 7990015 7998079 7999271 8003159 8012415 8018895 8025735 8030183 8034455 8043063 8043679 8045031 8046695 8062431 8070223 8074927 8083959 8087527 8091239 8097895 8099751 8101527 8104335 8105719 8110087 8118287 8120535 8124519 8130399 8136271 8138879 8140919 8146135 8146439 8147631 8148031 8148511 8150655 8152879 8155455 8156255 8159991 8163111 8165719 8170631 8173631 8176343 8176415 8196679 8213415 8215431 8217151 8218567 8233815 8249311 8276255 8282591 8285151 8287687 8290815 8292719 8295495 8296599 8297839 8299655 8301535 8302647 8305055 8305855 8308495 8309231 8309631 8309719 8311335 8316191 8318623 8328071 8333735 8336191 8337111 8340015 8343503 8356639 8359327 8365063 8367551 8368215 8369783 8382855 8384719 8397039 8405831 8416751 8418839 8419391 8426455 8437711 8438711 8452095 8454615 8456599 8459503 8462031 8464519 8468295 8469463 8474655 8477399 8483415 8484047 8486303 8488415 8495823 8517039 8517567 8517791 8518055 8528311 8544431 8546655 8555071 8559735 8563687 8564311 8569951 8574343 8576551 8579239 8582847 8596815 8608215 8620071 8626991 8633911 8638255 8639519 8652423 8673087 8687551 8687559 8690343 8693511 8697479 8697535 8699015 8702687 8713311 8717447 8717935 8728967 8732271 8764215 8764231 8765951 8777831 8781199 8785623 8795551 8807831 8818615 8822351 8831431 8832415 8850615 8859455 8862271 8863055 8870111 8871511 8876703 8884351 8888367 8903415 8906543 8909615 8927895 8938967 8941119 8953063 8967831 8980095 8990111 8993023 9005855 9015839 9015967 9016455 9018687 9019911 9020903 9023567 9031495 9035015 9035351 9052095 9059799 9061359 9065703 9071031 9077079 9078015 9083815 9084095 9086215 9087871 9090631 9092119 9093255 9101519 9105215 9105767 9115431 9116159 9119559 9125383 9129991 9135015 9138615 9154439 9157335 9175271 9177415 9179231 9179247 9179711 9192799 9206015 9215679 9221919 9222855 9223151 9225015 9229727 9233679 9247679 9248271 9249703 9252231 9253031 9255135 9264439 9265159 9269439 9269759 9270231 9279735 9282895 9298295 9308271 9335071 9335599 9338295 9339799 9341391 9341735 9342991 9350135 9350935 9361207 9364071 9366935 9371815 9384791 9393087 9400479 9405199 9405327 9424095 9427007 9432319 9433567 9434039 9435839 9447295 9453295 9455015 9455167 9458327 9462295 9466631 9471423 9471839 9474311 9476103 9477751 9479535 9479815 9480135 9490111 9491295 9492535 9495991 9497335 9499935 9503639 9507215 9514479 9517215 9517791 9521119 9523631 9526623 9530535 9531191 9533055 9537159 9537991 9552823 9554655 9556463 9566031 9572271 9572735 9573599 9585951 9588495 9600279 9601031 9605535 9607895 9614415 9618631 9620479 9629943 9632287 9635055 9638679 9639727 9640519 9652911 9653287 9655943 9658111 9661431 9662047 9662191 9666535 9671255 9692303 9696967 9697943 9700015 9702199 9705103 9713399 9718903 9720951 9726095 9729159 9731855 9736279 9738399 9753751 9755943 9759295 9771999 9773015 9779415 9779495 9781271 9783871 9791535 9794631 9799447 9801119 9815871 9819103 9819951 9822351 9825223 9827831 9833415 9849335 9854063 9854767 9856839 9864471 9875143 9889815 9890719 9894079 9895039 9915551 9916247 9924351 9927911 9934071 9934559 9935695 9936799 9947431 9949719 9950135 9952135 9956951 9960191 9960215 9962511 9969847 9984655 9987919 9991919 9997351